Skip to content →

Category: stories

quotes of the day

Published February 1, 2008 by lievenlb

Some people are in urgent need of a vacation, myself included…

From the paper Transseries for beginners by G.A. Edgar, arXived today :

Well, brothers and sisters, I am here today to tell you: If you love these formulas,
you need no longer hide in the shadows! The answer to all of these woes is here.
Transseries.

In a comment over at The Everthing Seminar

Shouldn’t dwarfs on the shoulders on giants be a little less arrogant?

by Micromegas.
Well, I’d rather enter a flame war than report about it. But, for some reason I cannot comment at the EverythingSeminar, nor at the SecretBloggingSeminar. Is this my problem or something to do with wordpress.com blogs? If you encountered a similar problem and managed to solve it, please let me know.

UPDATE (febr. 2) : my comment did surface after 5 days. Greg fished it out of their spam-filter. Thanks! I’ll try to comment at wordpress.com blogs from now on by NOT linking to neverendingbooks. I hope this will satisfy their spam-filter…

11 Comments

another numb3rs screenshot

Published January 28, 2008 by lievenlb

Ever since my accidental ‘discovery’ of the word CEILIDH written on a numb3rs blackboard, I keep an eye on their blackboards whenever I watch a new episode, and try to detect terms I might know. Here’s todays screen-shot

I had to choose one frame from a minute long shot (the ‘link’ on the left hand side is more recognizable in other frames). Anyway, here’s what I thought to recognize : a link, a quaternion-algebra over a number field,

$\begin{pmatrix} -1,-3 \\ \mathbb{Q}\sqrt{-2} \end{pmatrix} $ to be precise, and a $B^{max}_{order} $ in it. So did someone construct link-invariants from maximal orders in quaternion algebras? I surely didn’t know, but when in doubt there is always… google. I searched for ‘link invariant quaternion algebra maximal order’ and the third hit on page 2 gave me a pdf-file of a paper which seemed to have the relevant terms in it.

The paper is Automorphic forms and rational homology 3–spheres by Frank Calegari and Nathan Dunfield. Bingo! Their first figure is the ‘link’ drawn on the blackboard

which actually turns out to be a graph… This couldn’t be a coincidence, so as in the ceilidh-story, there had to be a connection with one of the authors. ‘Calegari+numb3rs’ didnt look promising but ‘Dunfield+numb3rs’ returned the hit Crime and Computation from CalTech News.

Krumholtz’s star turn as a math genius belies his dismal record as an algebra student. He explained that in preparation for his role he hung around Caltech last fall, “wandering the hallways and campus for two to three weeks,” to soak up the academic ambiance. To plumb character motivation he talked to a real-life youthful math guy, Caltech’s 30-year-old professor Dunfield.

In a phone interview shortly after the show’s television debut Dunfield recalled spending about an hour with Krumholtz, who plays 29-year-old Charlie. “He wanted to know what it’s like to do mathematics and work in academia, what types of things his character would likely be concerned about, like tenure or other issues.”

The professor, who was so un-starstruck that he hadn’t even made a point of watching the premiere, added, “He wanted to know, why would somebody choose to become a mathematics professor. Would they have to love math?” What was his response? The professor said he does not recall.

2 Comments

return of the cat ceilidh

Published January 24, 2008 by lievenlb

I couldn’t believe my eyes. I was watching an episode of numb3rs, ‘undercurrents’ to be precise, and there it was, circled in the middle of the blackboard, CEILIDH, together with some of the key-exchange maps around it…

Only, the plot doesn’t involve any tori-crypto… okay, there is an I-Ching-coded-tattoo which turns out to be a telephone number, but that’s all. Still, this couldn’t just be a coincidence. Googling for ‘ceilidh+numbers‘ gives as top hit the pdf-file of an article Alice in NUMB3Rland written by … Alice Silverberg (of the Rubin-Silverberg paper starting tori-cryptography). Alice turns out to be one of the unpaid consultants to the series. The 2-page article gives some insight into how ‘some math’ gets into the script

Typically, Andy emails a draft of the
script to the consultants. The FBI plot
is already in place, and the writers want
mathematics to go with it. The placeholder “math” in the draft is often nonsense or
jargon; the sort of things people with no
mathematical background might find by
Googling, and think was real math. Since
there’s often no mathematics that makes
sense in those parts of the script, the best
the consultants can do is replace jargon
that makes us cringe a lot with jargon that
makes us cringe a little.

From then on, it’s the Telephone Game.
The consultants email Andy our suggestions (“replace ‘our discrete universes’
with ‘our disjoint universes'”; “replace
the nonsensical ‘we’ve tried everything
-a full frequency analysis, a Vignere
deconstruction- we even checked for
a Lucas sequence’ with the slightly less
nonsensical ‘It’s much too short to try
any cryptanalysis on. If it were longer
we could try frequency analyses, or try
to guess what kind of cryptosystem it is
and use a specialized technique. For example, if it were a long enough Vigenere
cipher we could try a Kasiski test or an
index-of-coincidence analysis’). Andy
chooses about a quarter of my sugges-
tions and forwards his interpretation
of them to the writers and producers.
The script gets changed, and then the
actors ad lib something completely dif-
ferent (‘disjointed universes’: cute, but
loses the mathematical allusion; ‘Kasiski
exam’ : I didn’t mean that kind of ‘test’).

She ends her article with :

I have mixed feelings about NUMB3RS. I still have concerns about the violence, the depiction of women, and the pretense
that the math is accurate. However, if NUMB3RS could interest people in the power of mathematics enough for society
to greater value and support mathematics teaching, learning, and research, and
motivate more students to learnthat would be a positive step.

Further, there is a whole blog dedicated to some of the maths featuring in NUMB3RS, the numb3rs blog. And it was the first time I had to take a screenshot of a DVD, something usually off limits to the grab.app, but there is a simple hack to do it…

5 Comments