neverendingbooks

lieven le bruyn's blog

how noncommutative geometry shot itself

with 2 comments

I’ve never apologized for prolonged periods of blogsilence and have no intention to start now.

But, sometimes you need to expose the things holding you back before you can turn the page and (hopefully) start afresh.

Long time readers of this blog know I’ve often warned against group-think, personality cults and the making of exaggerate claims as possible threats to the survival of noncommutative geometry (for example in the group think post).

However, I was totally unprepared for this comment left on the noncommutative geometry blog, begin October:

Noncommutative Geometry is a field whose history is unpredictable.
When should I expect the pickaxe? Yours, Leon Trotsky

After sharing this on Google+ someone emailed suggesting I’d better have a look at some ‘semi-secret’ blogs. I did spend the better part of that friday going through more than 3 years worth of blogposts and cried my eyes out.

It is sad to read a message in a bottle and notice that after more than two years the matter is still far from resolved.

I wish you all a healing and liberating 2012!

Written by lievenlb

December 31st, 2011 at 3:40 pm

Posted in rants,stories

2 Responses to 'how noncommutative geometry shot itself'

Subscribe to comments with RSS

  1. She seems to be referring to Connes. As I too idolize both himself and Witten I was rather curious about the view from the inside.
    I do agree with her point though, science should always be about science.

    Errol

    5 Jan 12 at 2:01 am

  2. Errol: there is a reason the monotheistic religions ban idolatry.

    Bobito

    13 Jan 12 at 10:25 am

Leave a Reply