arXiv trackback wars

If you
happen to have a couple of hours to kill, you might have a look at the

arXiv trackback policy debate
over at Jacques Distler’s blog Musings. But before
you dive into this it is perhaps useful to glance at what went before.
Distler did pester (his wording, not mine) the arXiv to add
trackbacks from certain weblogs
to hep-th postings (i’m not aware of
math-papers having trackbacks). So far so good, the more information
about a paper the better i’d say, but it seems that not all weblogs’
trackbacks are allowed… A small commitee has the power to divide
hep-th people into ‘crackpots’ or ‘active researchers’
(mother nature may very well decide to add all stringtheorists from the
second category to the first in a couple of years… but, i’m
digressing) and accordingly censor specific blogs and frustrate their
authors, Peter Woit’s blog Not Even
Wrong
being the main victim. The whole trackback-policy is yet
another futile academics power-game. Futile because there is an obvious
way around it : type into Technorati either the arXiv-number
or title or author and you will get all (!) weblog postings mentioning
the paper (Technorati even has a slider if you only want to read
postings with ‘authority’ rather than all). Perhaps one of the
more tech-abled stringtheorists should spend an afternoon to write a
bookmarklet
to perform this trick from any arXiv abstract
page…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>